What Went Wrong And Why

Hello everyone!

I’m sure there was some euphoria and some disappointment this morning after expecting to wake up to a raging blizzard and instead seeing some light snow and a little wind. To be fair, some areas are right on forecast with heavy snow and near zero visibility. A highly localized band of snow set up over Coastal York County who did pretty well for this storm. Eastern MA should do ok as well as 20″ reports are already streaming in from the North Shore.

This post will deal more with the widespread blizzard that wasn’t for Maine and New Hampshire. That being said, high winds will still whip around the snow we already have on the ground and cause reduced visibility and whatever new snow fell last night will add to that. Temps will still be cold and thus wind chills will continue to be a threat.

First Factor: Upper Level Low

0000000
Image Credit: Accuweather

Yesterday morning the blizzard forecast was on. Models predicted a strong and strengthening upper low off NYC with tons of energy off of Southern New England. All this energy would translate into a strong and rapidly strengthening storm and thus lots of snow was predicted.

00000000
Image Credit: Accuweather

Yesterday evening’s models picked up on the weakness of the upper low and thus the forecast changed drastically. Notice the two weak upper low centers in the image above. This showed a lack of organization and thus prevented moisture from being wrapped in as easily and as quickly. Remember, this disturbance came directly from the Arctic which means lots of cold and no moisture. Basically the entire forecast hinged on the upper low being strong enough to wrap in Atlantic moisture which did not happen. We are now left with a strong surface low that has very little moisture, and thus very little heavy precip,  on the NW side.

Second Factor: Lack Of Energy For Banding

000000000000000
Image Credit: Accuweather

Here is yesterday morning’s GFS showing lots of frontogenesis across the area. Frontogenesis can basically be thought of as fuel for heavy snow bands. Lots of frontogenesis (shown above) creates lots of heavy bands. This was yet another factor that contributed to what was a high confidence forecast for blizzard conditions and lots of snow.

00000000000000
Image Credit: Accuweather

Once again, yesterday’s models changed their mind. Notice the lack of the pinks and reds in yesterday’s evening run. Without as much fuel, heavy bands were confined to very small areas (Boston and York County) while the rest of us saw flurries. Bands down in Boston even caused thundersnow however the tremendous amounts of energy that was used up by those bands came at the expense of other areas of heavy snow that were trying to form last night.

The Result: Less Snow

000000000000
Image Credit: Accuweather

Now let’s look at the surface map from yesterday’s morning run. notice all the dark greens in the blue circle showing heavy snow. Without upper air support, those couldn’t happen. Yesterday’s evening run finally picked up on that and showed any dark green confined to Eastern MA.

0000000000000
Image Credit: Accuweather 

Here is yesterday’s evening run showing the dark green confined to eastern MA which matches what’s happening this morning very well.

eastma
Radar Image From 9 AM Shows SE MA Getting Pounded. Image Credit: NWS

Had the storm been about 100/150 miles NW of where it is now, those bands would have been over us and the forecast would have verified.

vis0
This Morning’s Visible Satellite Image Showing Our Storm Just A Little Bit Too Far Offshore To Bring Widespread Heavy Snow. Image Credit: PSU E-Wall

Regardless of how hard the forecast busted, the storm still looks really cool on the visible satellite this morning. See the eye?

Our next storm threats arrive Wednesday (probably light if anything) and next weekend (still very uncertain).

-Jack

3 thoughts on “What Went Wrong And Why”

  1. Jack,

    Your explanation (³What went wrong and why²) illuminates the situation with outstanding clarity. I had been studying the situation with my limited skills and suspected that the storm would be too far east and that it would not close off soon enough for northern Connecticut to get the weather that NOAA advertised. When I tried to explain to Ruthanne and our friends why the NOAA forecast would not verify, their eyes glazed over and, basically, I lost the audience. If I had only read your post, which put all the ingredients together in such a way that I could have transmitted a message that could have easily been understood, I would have been the hero instead of the weather geek!

    So. Thanks! And you rock!

    ‹Ron Marchetti

    From: Forecasterjack Reply-To: Forecasterjack Date: Sunday, February 15, 2015 at 9:12 AM To: Microsoft Office User Subject: [New post] What Went Wrong And Why

    WordPress.com Jack Sillin posted: “Hello everyone! I’m sure there was some euphoria and some disappointment this morning after expecting to wake up to a raging blizzard and instead seeing some light snow and a little wind. To be fair, some areas are right on forecast with heavy snow and”

  2. Jack: Thanks for the report on the weather this morning which was not quite wat was expected. Here at 5 a.m. it was windy with blowing snow off roofs and the ground. Didn’t seem to be anything from the sky. It is still windy this afternoon with blowing surface snow. The barometer is steady at 29.6 and the outdoor window sill reading is 24 degrees. Gramps

Leave a comment